Quantitative Research Article Appraisal
Purpose
The purpose of this assignment is to provide the graduate nursing student opportunity to practice reading and critiquing research articles for application to an evidence-based practice.
Course Outcomes
Integrate evidence-based practice and research to support advancement of holistic nursing care in diverse healthcare settings. (PO 1)
Integrate knowledge related to evidence-based practice and person-centered care to improve healthcare outcomes. (PO 1, 5)
Develop knowledge related to research and evidence-based practice as a basis for designing and critiquing research studies. (PO 1, 5)
Analyze research findings and evidence-based practice to advanced holistic nursing care initiatives that promote positive healthcare outcomes. (PO 1,5)
Due Date: Sunday, 11:59 PM CT
Total Points Possible: 130 Points
Requirements
Article Review Steps
Step 1: Go to the Chamberlain Library and select a quantitative research article of your topic of interest published within the last three (3) years.
Step 2: Write a two-page critique of the article in a Word Doc integrating course readings.
Step 3: Complete the Johns Hopkins Quantitative Research Appraisal Tool (Links to an external site.).
Step 4: Upload your Word doc analysis with the Johns Hopkins Research Appraisal Tool (in the appendix) to TurnItIn.
Content of critique should include at a minimum:
Participant sampling,
Questionnaires/tools,
Ethics,
Analysis of findings,
Limitations,
Discussion section,
Summary: Application (translation) to practice specialty, and future implications.
Preparing the Assignment:
APA Format According to 6th edition.
Word Doc per assignment requirements
Word Doc Format:
Cover page, no abstract, introduction (no heading per APA), body of the paper/review, reference list, appendix with Johns Hopkins appraisal doc. For review sections refer to your readings and the Johns Hopkins Research Appraisal Tool.
Article title, author, journal, publication date
Evidence level and quality
Analysis of the study methodology (specific to study type, e.g., qualitative versus quantitative versus non-research)
Reference List should include the chosen article and other resources used to construct the review, such as course textbook, Johns Hopkins Evidence Based Practice: Model and Guidelines (2018), and How to Read a Paper by Greenhalgh (2014).
| Evidence level and quality rating: |
|
| Article title: | Number: |
| Author(s): | Publication date: |
| Journal: | |
| Setting: | Sample (composition and size): |
| Does this evidence address my EBP question?
Yes No-Do not proceed with appraisal of this evidence |
|
| Is this study:
QuaNtitative (collection, analysis, and reporting of numerical data) Go to Section I: QuaNtitative QuaLitative(collection, analysis, and reporting of narrative data) Go to Section II: QuaLitative Mixed methods (results reported both numerically and narratively) Go to Section III: Mixed Methods |
|
| Section I: QuaNtitative | ||
| Level of Evidence (Study Design) | ||
| Is this a report of a single research study? | o Yes | o No Go to B |
| 1. Was there manipulation of an independent variable? | o Yes | o No |
| 2. Was there a control group? | o Yes | o No |
| 3. Were study participants randomly assigned to the intervention and control groups? | o Yes | o No |
| If Yes to questions 1, 2, and 3, this is a randomized controlled trial (RCT) or experimental study. | LEVEL I | |
| If Yes to questions 1 and 2 and No to question 3orYes to question 1 and No to questions 2 and 3, this is quasi-experimental. (Some degree of investigator control, some manipulation of an independent variable, lacks random assignment to groups, and may have a control group). |
LEVEL II | |
| If No to questions 1, 2, and 3, this is nonexperimental. (No manipulation of independent variable; can be descriptive, comparative, or correlational; often uses secondary data). |
LEVEL III | |
| Study Findings That Help Answer the EBP Question | ||
| Skip to the Appraisal of QuaNtitative Research Studies section | ||
| Section I: QuaNtitative (continued) | ||||
| Is this a summary of multiple sources of research evidence? | o Yes Continue |
o No Use Appendix F |
||
| 1. Does it employ a comprehensive search strategy and rigorous appraisal method?
If this study includes research, nonresearch, and experiential evidence, it is an integrative review (see Appendix F). |
o Yes Continue |
o No Use Appendix F |
||
2. For systematic reviews and systematic reviews with meta-analysis |
||||
| a. Are all studies included RCTs? | LEVEL I | |||
| b. Are the studies a combination of RCTs and quasi-experimental, or quasi-experimental only? | LEVEL II | |||
| c. Are the studies a combination of RCTs, quasi-experimental, and nonexperimental, or non- experimental only? | LEVEL III | |||
| A systematic review employs a search strategy and a rigorous appraisal method, but does not generate an effect size.
A meta-analysis, or systematic review with meta-analysis, combines and analyzes results from studies to generate a new statistic: the effect size. |
||||
| Study Findings That Help Answer the EBP Question | ||||
| Skip to the Appraisal of Systematic Review (With or Without a Meta-Analysis) section | ||||
| Appraisal of QuaNtitative Research Studies | |||
| Does the researcher identify what is known and not known about the problem and how the study will address any gaps in knowledge? | o Yes | o No | |
| Was the purpose of the study clearly presented? | o Yes | o No | |
| Was the literature review current (most sources within the past five years or a seminal study)? | o Yes | o No | |
| Was sample size sufficient based on study design and rationale? | o Yes | o No | |
| If there is a control group:
· Were the characteristics and/or demographics similar in both the control and intervention groups? |
o Yes | o No |
N/A |
| · If multiple settings were used, were the settings similar? | o Yes | o No | N/A |
| · Were all groups equally treated except for the intervention group(s)? | o Yes | o No | N/A |
| Are data collection methods described clearly? | o Yes | o No | |
| Were the instruments reliable (Cronbach’sa[alpha] > 0.70)? | o Yes | o No | N/A |
| Was instrument validity discussed? | o Yes | o No | N/A |
| If surveys or questionnaires were used, was the response rate > 25%? |
o Yes | o No | N/A |
| Were the results presented clearly? | o Yes | o No | |
| If tables were presented, was the narrative consistent with the table content? | o Yes | o No | N/A |
| Were study limitations identified and addressed? | o Yes | o No | |
| Were conclusions based on results? | o Yes | o No | |
| Complete theQuality Rating for QuaNtitative Studiessection | |||
| Appraisal of Systematic Review (With or Without Meta-Analysis) | ||
| Were the variables of interest clearly identified? | o Yes | o No |
| Was the search comprehensive and reproducible?
· Key search terms stated |
o Yes | o No |
| · Multiple databases searched and identified | o Yes | o No |
| · Inclusion and exclusion criteria stated | o Yes | o No |
| Was there a flow diagram that included the number of studies eliminated at each level of review? | o Yes | o No |
| Were details of included studies presented (design, sample, methods, results, outcomes, strengths, and limitations)? | o Yes | o No |
| Were methods for appraising the strength of evidence (level and quality) described? | o Yes | o No |
| Were conclusions based on results? | o Yes | o No |
| · Results were interpreted | o Yes | o No |
| · Conclusions flowed logically from the interpretation and systematic review question | o Yes | o No |
| Did the systematic review include a section addressing limitations andhow they were addressed? | o Yes | o No |
| Complete theQuality Rating for QuaNtitative Studies section (below) | ||
| Quality Rating for QuaNtitative Studies |
| Circle the appropriate quality rating below:
A High quality: Consistent, generalizable results; sufficient sample size for the study design; adequate control; definitive conclusions; consistent recommendations based on comprehensive literature review that includes thorough reference to scientific evidence. B Good quality: Reasonably consistent results; sufficient sample size for the study design; some control, and fairly definitive conclusions; reasonably consistent recommendations based on fairly comprehensive literature review that includes some reference to scientific evidence. C Low quality or major flaws: Little evidence with inconsistent results; insufficient sample size for the study design; conclusions cannot be drawn. |
| Section II: QuaLitative | ||||
| Level of Evidence (Study Design) | ||||
Is this a report of a single research study? |
o Yes |
o No |
||
| Study Findings That Help Answer the EBP Question
|
||||
| Complete theAppraisal of Single QuaLitative Research Studysection(below) | ||||
| Appraisal of a Single QuaLitative Research Study | ||
| Was there a clearly identifiable and articulated:
· Purpose? |
❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · Researchquestion? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · Justificationformethod(s)used? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · Phenomenonthatisthefocusoftheresearch? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Were study sample participants representative? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Did they have knowledge of or experience with the research area? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Were participant characteristics described? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Was sampling adequate, as evidenced by achieving saturation of data? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Data analysis:
· Was a verification process used in every step by checking and confirming with participants the trustworthiness of analysis and interpretation? |
❑ Yes |
❑ No |
| · Was there a description of how data were analyzed (i.e., method), by computer or manually? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Do findings support the narrative data (quotes)? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Do findings flow from research question to data collected to analysis undertaken? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Are conclusions clearly explained? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Skip to theQuality Rating for QuaLitative Studiessection | ||
ForsummariesofmultiplequaLitativeresearchstudies(meta-synthesis), wasacomprehensivesearchstrategyandrigorousappraisalmethodused? |
o Yes Level III |
o No go to Appendix F |
||
| Study Findings That Help Answer the EBP Question | ||||
| Complete the Appraisal of Meta-Synthesis Studies section (below) | ||||
| Appraisal of Meta-Synthesis Studies | ||
| Were the search strategy and criteria for selecting primary studies clearly defined? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Were findings appropriate and convincing? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Was a description of methods used to:
· Compare findings from each study? |
❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · Interpret data? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Did synthesis reflect: | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · New insights? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · Discovery of essential features of phenomena? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| · A fuller understanding of the phenomena? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Was sufficient data presented to support the interpretations? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No |
| Complete the Quality Rating for QuaLititative Studies section (below) | ||
| Quality Rating for QuaLitative Studies |
| Circle the appropriate quality rating below:
No commonly agreed-on principles exist for judging the quality of quaLitative studies. It is a subjective process based on the extent to which study data contributes to synthesis and how much information is known about the researchers’ efforts to meet the appraisal criteria. For meta-synthesis, there is preliminary agreement that quality assessments should be made before synthesis to screen out poor-quality studies1. A/B High/Good quality is used for single studies and meta-syntheses2. The report discusses efforts to enhance or evaluate the quality of the data and the overall inquiry in sufficient detail; and it describes the specific techniques used to enhance the quality of the inquiry. Evidence of some or all of the following is found in the report: · Transparency: Describes how information was documented to justify decisions, how data were reviewed by others, and how themes and categories were formulated. · Diligence: Reads and rereads data to check interpretations; seeks opportunity to find multiple sources to corroborate evidence. · Verification: The process of checking, confirming, and ensuring methodologic coherence. · Self-reflection and self-scrutiny: Being continuously aware of how a researcher’s experiences, background, or prejudices might shape and bias analysis and interpretations. · Participant-driven inquiry: Participants shape the scope and breadth of questions; analysis and interpretation give voice to those who participated. · Insightful interpretation: Data and knowledge are linked in meaningful ways to relevant literature. CLower-quality studies contribute little to the overall review of findings and have few, if any, of the features listed for High/Good quality. |
1 https://www.york.ac.uk/crd/SysRev/!SSL!/WebHelp/6_4_ASSESSMENT_OF_QUALITATIVE_RESEARCH.htm
2 Adapted from Polit & Beck (2017).
| Section III: Mixed Methods | ||
| Level of Evidence (Study Design) | ||
| You will need to appraise both the quaNtitative and quaLitative parts of the study independently, before appraising the study in its entirety. | ||
| 1. Evaluate the quaNitative part of the study using Section I. | Level | Quality |
| Insert here the level of evidence and overall quality for this part: | ||
| 2. Evaluate the quaLitative part of the study using Section II. | Level | Quality |
| Insert here the level of evidence and overall quality for this part: | ||
| 3. To determine the level of evidence, circle the appropriate study design: | ||
| · Explanatory sequential designs collect quaNtitative data first, followed by the quaLitative data; and their purpose is to explain quaNtitative results using quaLitative findings. The level is determined based on the level of the quaNtitative part.
· Exploratory sequential designs collect quaLitative data first, followed by the quaNtitative data; and their purpose is to explain quaLitative findings using the quaNtitative results. The level is determined based on the level of the quaLitative part, and it is always Level III. · Convergent parallel designs collect the quaLitative and quaNtitative data concurrently for the purpose of providing a more complete understanding of a phenomenon by merging both datasets. These designs are Level III. · Multiphasic designs collect quaLitative and quaNtitative data over more than one phase, with each phase informing the next phase. These designs are Level III. |
||
| Study Findings That Help Answer the EBP Question | ||
| Complete the Appraisal of Mixed Methods Studiessection (below) | ||
| Appraisal of Mixed Methods Studies3 | |||
| Wasthemixed-methodsresearchdesignrelevanttoaddressthe quaNtitative and quaLitative research questions (orobjectives)? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No | ❑ N/A |
| WastheresearchdesignrelevanttoaddressthequaNtitativeand quaLitative aspects of the mixed-methods question (orobjective)? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No | ❑ N/A |
| Forconvergentparalleldesigns,wastheintegrationofquaNtitative andquaLitativedata(orresults)relevanttoaddresstheresearch question orobjective? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No | ❑ N/A |
| For convergent parallel designs, were the limitations associated withtheintegration(forexample,thedivergenceofquaLitativeand quaNtitative data or results) sufficientlyaddressed? | ❑ Yes | ❑ No | ❑ N/A |
| Complete theQuality Rating for Mixed-Method Studies section (below) | |||
3 National Collaborating Centre for Methods and Tools. (2015). Appraising Qualitative, Quantitative, and Mixed Methods Studies included in Mixed Studies Reviews: The MMAT. Hamilton, ON: McMaster University. (Updated 20 July, 2015) Retrieved from http://www.nccmt.ca/resources/search/232
| Quality Rating for Mixed-Methods Studies |
| Circle the appropriate quality rating below
A Highquality:Containshigh-qualityquaNtitativeandquaLitativestudycomponents;highlyrelevant studydesign;relevantintegrationofdataorresults;andcarefulconsiderationofthelimitationsof thechosenapproach. B Goodquality:Containsgood-qualityquaNtitativeandquaLitativestudycomponents;relevantstudy design;moderatelyrelevantintegrationofdataorresults;andsomediscussionoflimitationsof integration. CLow quality or major flaws: Contains low quality quaNtitative and quaLitative study components; studydesignnotrelevanttoresearchquestionsorobjectives;poorlyintegrateddataorresults;and noconsiderationoflimitsofintegration. |
We've got everything to become your favourite writing service
Money back guarantee
Your money is safe. Even if we fail to satisfy your expectations, you can always request a refund and get your money back.
Confidentiality
We don’t share your private information with anyone. What happens on our website stays on our website.
Our service is legit
We provide you with a sample paper on the topic you need, and this kind of academic assistance is perfectly legitimate.
Get a plagiarism-free paper
We check every paper with our plagiarism-detection software, so you get a unique paper written for your particular purposes.
We can help with urgent tasks
Need a paper tomorrow? We can write it even while you’re sleeping. Place an order now and get your paper in 8 hours.
Pay a fair price
Our prices depend on urgency. If you want a cheap essay, place your order in advance. Our prices start from $11 per page.