Program Evaluation Assignment | Essay Help Services

I would like you to please ensure that all the information needed is included in the text as well as any corrections in clarity and grammar, please… I am posting the instructions for the paper as well as the writing

Program Evaluation

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Program Evaluation Assignment | Essay Help Services
For $10/Page 0nly
Order Essay

Proposal Layout Guide

 

Develop and improve, on the basis of assessment, a program evaluation proposal with the following sections. (These items will not be completed in exactly the order listed because some central decisions control how all parts integrate. As changes occur, sections must be adjusted accordingly.  The instructors recommend use of the outline in Figure 15.1 (Royse, Thyer & Padgett, 2010, p. 388) and Box 15.1 (Royse, Thyer & Padgett, 2010, p. 374).  All of Chapter 15 should be considered when completing the final paper/report for this course.) Please write all sections in future tense except the hypothetical agency description (present tense) and the literature review (present or past depending on the type of citation).  In all writing for Bellevue University, APA formatting is expected (Currently, 6th Edition).

 

  1. Executive Summary: An overview of the entire report, focused on a broad introduction of the topic and evaluation outcomes and recommendations.  (20 Points)
  2. Introduction section:
    • Description of the problem or issue to be explored. This is a high level introduction of the topic.  (Specifics about your program evaluation question will follow in the third element of the Introduction Section.)  Be specific and describe evidence indicating that program processes or outcomes may be below standards or that there is room for improvement.  This may include concern that regulatory requirements are not being met, funding sources may question program viability, other questions that concern stakeholders (including the clients). (15 points)
    • Program description and background. This puts the issue being explored into context. Succinctly describe the agency in terms of any of the following that are relevant—and add others if needed. This may start as “bullets” but is to written in about 3 well-organized and focused paragraphs in the final version. (35 points)
      1. Main mission, 2-3 highlights in the history of the organization
      2. Top three service goals or strategies related to carrying out the mission
  • Information about the theoretical foundation of the model of care,

i.e., What makes change happen in the program?

  1. Top two qualities or skills needed by the director and by the main direct service staff
  2. Description of case or work loads of main service staff
  3. Estimated budget and sources of finances (keep this global and very brief)
  • Top 2-3 results of a recent “needs analysis” (this usually will be hypothetical for purposes of this course) of what service needs there are in the community that the agency can address
  • Top 2 results of a previous program evaluation or accreditation report, i.e., What are areas needing improvement within the agency?
  1. Two indicators of the skills and attitudes of the board of directors
  2. Two indicators of the skills and attitudes of other significant stakeholders
  3. Two indicators of community awareness of the agency and of degree of acceptance of its services as essential
  • Two examples of media coverage of the agency and its work

 Purpose of the evaluation and rationale for it. This section brings the problem together with your program.  State the “focus” or hypothesis of the program evaluation proposal. The focus should be about an issue or problem with a main element or process in the agency’s model of care that is of concern at this point in time. For example, a focus might be on whether all the skills needed in a parenting program have been learned adequately to make it likely that better child outcomes will result in the future. Although future outcomes are mentioned, the real focus is an intermediate concern about whether the education program is being delivered properly, i.e., with “fidelity” (see chapter 14 in the text). In other words, it is likely that your program evaluation is a component part of a larger chain of research.  Describe/review the appropriate type of program evaluations, e.g., needs assessment, formative, process, quality assurance/monitoring, and summative/outcomes. (20 points)

  1. Literature Review section: Identify and summarize (in about one page) relevant knowledge contained in at least three substantive articles about the issues and methods proposed in this program evaluation proposal. Respond to the items for Literature Review in Figure 15.1. (20 points)
  2. Method section: In general, follow the pattern suggested for Methodology in Box 15.1. Method section: Investigation of the focus requires operational description of how data will be gathered to “test” the hypothesis. Describe the participants, the design (see the text for the main types of research designs used in evaluation research), measures, data collection processes (include informed consent form in the appendix), and a description of data analysis technique(s), e.g., time series graphs, t-test. (35 points)
  3. Results section: Describe the expected results from the data analysis. This should be a short paragraph providing a hypothetical trend expectation from the main data collected. (5 points)
  4. Discussion/Recommendations section: Hypothesize the top 2-3 direct practice ways the expected results could be put to practical use. This may include making changes related to the focus of the program evaluation research, may suggest further study to clarify or overcome limitations, etc. (15 points)
  5. References section: APA format required; APA style will be graded. (15 points)
  6. Appendix: List items in a table of contents on the first page after the Reference section; then put each of the following—you can add or delete as relevant—on a separate page (20 points):
    • An original consent form (can adapt an existing model) that informs potential participants of the purpose, types of responses and methods needed, how their personal information will be handled—keep HIPAA in mind, and how the results will be disseminated and used
    • An original or adapted scale or survey with a logical, clear design and wording
    • Data collection plan
    • Data collection forms or tables (use mock data to test whether the forms will be suitable but do NOT present these mock data in the Results sections).
    • Data summary tables (use some mock data to test—do NOT present in the Results section)
    • Description of proposed meetings to communicate with various types of stakeholders—indicate a few agenda items needed for presenting and getting approval of your proposal.
    • Other relevant documents, e.g., brochures, bibliography (as opposed to the cited items that are in the Reference section)

 

You are expected to improve the proposal based on assessment feedback received on your rough draft; rough draft should include all elements.  Always consider communication, critical thinking, composition, APA manuscript style, and internal consistency; use the rubric, APA checklist, grammar checker and other tools as part of your assessments—be systematic in the process.

 

Yeled v’ Yaldah Head Start Program Evaluation

Elisheva Deutsch

Bellevue University

 

 

 

 

 

 

Executive Summary

The quality of service provision through individualized education programs for children with special needs has continued to raise debate on whether organizations are observing the legal stipulations or just fulfilling their selfish interests through the programs. The current projection of services shows that the organization is not producing better than average results in fulfilling this promise among the marginalized group of children living with disabilities and special needs. From this evaluation, the program’s management will easily identify the strong and weak points of the special needs resources. The segregation of children with special needs was introduced as a measure of protecting children from other children, not as a tool for promoting equal benefits from the education curriculum. It is recommended that more therapists and counselors should be incorporated into the program to address the increasing demand for mental health services among children.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Introduction

The Yeled v’ Yaldah Early Childhood Head Start Program was founded by a group of stakeholders that were interested in protecting community children through a home and school-based application. The program serves the community in Brooklyn and Staten Island. There are concerns among investors that the Head Start program is not doing enough to resolve the problems of inequalities that socially excluded communities continue to experience. The Head Start Program has made strides in accommodating children with disabilities or special needs. However, there is further room for improvement in the services that the program currently offers to these marginalized groups. The program has adopted different efforts to increase the support it shows to the children as a measure of meeting the regulatory requirements. Yet, there seems to be a decrease in the efforts to comprehensively include children with disabilities in the inclusive activities offered by the Yeled v’ Yaldah Organization.

According to the official website of the organization, Yeled v’ Yaldah’s not-for-profit service is funded through federal grants. The aim of the agency is “to offer a seamless blend of child care and developmental services, as well as health and nutritional guidance (Yeled V’Yaldah, 2005).” The current projection of services shows that the organization is not producing better than average results in fulfilling this promise among the historically marginalized group of children living with disabilities and special needs. In a population of 1,300 children that the program supports, the policy only requires that the mandatory 10% is assigned to children with special needs. Thus, Yeled v’ Yaldah’s program should implement strategies that promote inclusive education as a medium for solving the gap in cognitive development between children with special needs and their counterparts. Additionally, more should be done in other departments involving social life and access to quality healthcare to improve the social welfare of every child without discrimination.

Every child with special needs or disabilities wants access to the same lifestyle that many other children have, such as friends, fun, and health care. Therefore Yeled v’ Yaldah’s program should aim to attain an inclusion policy and exceed the minimum requirements that have been displayed to perpetuate the alienation of children with special needs. Furthermore, the program should address the problem of inequality in the division of resources to socially excluded groups. To resolve this historical problem, the current level of strategies continues to alienate the marginalized groups by creating specialized programs that remove the children from the “typical” education programs. Effective solutions should attempt to integrate the special needs groups into the standard programs while providing the same amenities required to special needs children.

The flow of resources that the group provides to children with special needs is a troubling problem referred to as intra school separation. The problem with separation from other kids and providing a different syllabus to the special needs children is that it slowly cumulates disadvantages that constrain the disabled children in living fulfilling lives after school. The social and psychological effects of continually alienating children with special needs are mirrored in the performance of the students in standard development tests. The recommendations that come out of these evaluations should help the program in improving the combination of strategies that help students with disabilities and those without. The early childhood programs of the Head Start program plays an essential role in the development of views regarding living with disability in society. The current policy is based on a transitional time when children with a disability were being integrated into the curriculum, and specific programs were created. These programs clearly defined the characteristics and children who qualified for special education. Previous research studies show that features such as gender, race, and class have a profound effect on one’s adult life. The use of special education programs has a similar impact on the life of children living with disabilities, and this should not be the case. Before children with disabilities were offered the opportunity to learn, many people in society believed that the children had no chance of developing their cognitive awareness. A fully effective inclusion strategy of young children living with disabilities should not stop at creating separate programs for the minimum required number of students, but to expand the access to all general activities and child welfare.

  1. Program Description and Background
  2. The History of Yeled v’ Yalda

The program began with a total of 78 children at the Head Start Center, which has since seen over 3,000 children receive developmental training at the facility or through the home-based programs. The founding CEO, Solomon Igel’s background as an Orthodox Jew and has directed the values of the teachers and social workers who represent the agency. He dreamed of a school that would offer children more than formal education, as the school would emphasize creating a ‘whole child’ by focusing on the health, social, and economic factors in the learners’ lives. The management of the agency comprises of a board of directors carefully selected from the community in Brooklyn. The decisions of the board are audited annually by the federal and state agencies, as well as an internal evaluation such as this proposal that attempts to improve the service provided to the community. The agency has continued to garner more support in a time when many other similar organizations are closing down due to the emphasis on involving the whole community and respect for the diverse cultures.

The low-income families in the society are the leading target market for the organization as the management continuously expands the communication media to reach this population. The improvement of the facilities and resources provided for child welfare can only achieve success if the visibility and sustainability of the agency are equal across all families irrespective of the needs and location. To do this, the YvY agency employs a blended funding model that combines different sources of funding that leverage each other’s strengths and weaknesses to account for the budget deficits (Citigroup, 2020). In the last few years, the agency introduced fee-based services as an avenue for collecting more money that is reinvested into other programs. Since the low-income families are characteristically non-speaking and congested, the agency faces more pressure in offering social services as their needs go beyond learning only.

  1. Key Staff

The needs of the target population for the YvY Agency is too complex and requires a dedicated, professional, and well-knowledgeable staff to carry out the responsibilities bestowed on them. The mission statement and funding are only crucial with the adequate team in place. The agency staff comprises of teachers, social workers, and healthcare workers who are carefully chosen to ensure that they have a propensity to serve others in the community. The organizational culture adopted as the organization supports a structural approach and an effective communication policy that blends all the operations to reach the families in need. The recruiting process is overseen by the head of the program, and the essential qualifications the agency looks for is the ability to speak more than one language and certification from professional bodies.

The strategies employed in social work changes every few months in an attempt to keep up with the evidence-based practices that are shown to produce better results among young learners. As such, the YvY formulates formal and informal training programs that are geared towards improving the skills of the staff who can, in turn, provide the best services to the families and children they work with daily.

The management of the agency comprises of a director of education services, director of finance or comptroller, and the director of special services. However, the organization ensures that the decision-making process involves other stakeholders such as business people and parents since it evokes a feeling of commitment to the people that the agency serves. The organization currently has over 20 facilities that are leased from the business community through this has inevitably led to more complications in making the facilities accessible to marginalized groups. The YvY Agency is improving these services by focusing on creating lasting relationships with parents and volunteers to supplement the overworked core staff.

iii. Measures of Success and Community Involvement:

Since the leading financial investor in the Head Start Program is from the federal grant, the management has to adhere to the review strategies used by the federal government. This evaluation examines child welfare services, engagement with the surrounding community, and the suitability of the structural design to achieve the objectives of the program.

Aside from the overall measurement of success, the program carries out frequent tests on the young learners to understand the level of growth and development over a certain period; six months and one-year intervals. The learning programs are well documented by the teachers and social workers; this data provides more useful information such as the enrollment numbers, withdrawal, and the trends in attendance or absenteeism. For instance, YvY has a long waiting list of families that are interested in their children joining the program. However, due to the budget limitations, the program selects students based on the level of need, parent’s involvement, and the legal stipulations, which is used to recruit children with special needs to arrive at the mandatory quota. It is expected that once the facility at 1257-63 38th Street in Brooklyn is completed, the agency will double its intake rate. The withdrawal rates from the program is a meager 5%, which mostly arises from the relocation of families from the locations of our facilities to other states for reasons not related to child welfare. The program posts a high number of transitions from the early childhood Head Start programs to mid-year classes. Additionally, the long waiting list allows the program to replace learners who are removed from the program instantly.

  1. Purpose of the Evaluation

The primary purpose of this evaluation is to examine the preparedness of the program in providing services to children with disabilities beyond the legal scope or mandatory requirements set by the law. Contemporary research continues to show that there are inadequacies within the strategies that were earlier adopted as methodologies of including children living with disabilities into the mainstream education system. YvY applied for certification from the state Department of Health to become a certified service provider of special education in all the centers. The agency implements the individualized education plan in which the social and background of the learner is included in creating a customized routine that will allow a ‘whole’ development of the cognitive, physical, and mental health. The critical problem with the program is that it endeavors to address the social welfare of the children to a maximum of the parameters that are set by the city and legal requirements.

The type of evaluation approach used in this evaluation is significantly determined by the processes and information that is required to understand the level of service provision to the minority group. The services offered to the community through the program are improved through thorough evaluation of the effects they produce on a child’s development irrespective of the individual differences. From this evaluation, the program’s management will easily identify the strong and weak points of the special needs resources. This information is used to create a needs analysis and recommendations that can be used to improve the whole program to help create an environment where all kids interact without structural limitations construed as separate learning programs. The goal of an evaluation is to identify the processes that are working or those that are performing at under-full capacities, such as the services offered to special needs children. The current level of services is geared towards obeying the rule of law, rather than improvement of service using evidence-based strategies that fulfill the funding capabilities that the agency receives from different donors.

The YvY Agency evaluation process will follow the principles of process evaluation methodology. This type of evaluation focuses on the activities within a program that are thought to lack the quality in offering a given service to a specific audience. The benefit of this type of evaluation is that it is easy to carry out when the operations are ongoing, as it is more suitable to observe the activities and the outcomes from child development. The three key features of any program are the inputs, outputs, and activities that create a logical flow from one unit to the next. The evaluators will determine if the failure to produce better integration of students with special needs arises from the breakdown in the implementation process or merely a lack of evidence-based research to model improvements. The process evaluation answers questions regarding who, when, what, and where of the program. For instance, in the case of YvY preparedness to handle the care of special needs children, the following questions must be considered:

  • Who are the target group of the program, and how has it evolved over the years?
  • What is the program doing to reach all members of this group?
  • What are the current barriers that make it hard to arrive at the required standards of excellence?
  • Is there room for improvement or additional activities to be introduced in the program?
  • Are all the services offered suitable for the development of the children, irrespective of categorization as special needs or typical?

Through this evaluation, it will be possible to account for the differences in outcomes between the different groups of interest. For instance, the use of separate classes, in addition to the standard curriculum, increases the workload on children with disabilities. In contrast, the creation of an independent curriculum denies children access to equal learning opportunities. The process evaluation technique also helps the evaluators to identify the trickling side effects that the program produces in the lives of learners at the school and after graduation from the program. The premise of this evaluation is to provide a more practical approach that will encourage wholesome inclusion to produce better socially-integration of children living with disabilities.

Literature Review

The historical perspective of how children with special needs and disabilities have been treated in the education and child welfare sectors has progressed over the years after the government had to react to the demands of parents. For instance, the Individual with Disabilities Education Improvement Act of 2004 introduced the measures that education and social welfare agencies have to inculcate in practice during the intervention and training of children living with special needs. The Act is divided into three sections that focus on the child, the family relations, and the special education programs. The first step in the emasculation of a child with special needs is to define the parameters used to identify and refer a child with disabilities to a special education program. The second and third phases involve an evaluation and determination of the child’s eligibility to join a given program. The above process must be evaluated by a professional who will work together with other stakeholders to formulate an individualized education program that is suitable for young learners. At the time of introduction, the IEP was the most advanced form of education that offered the best chance for children with disabilities to access any educational services. The IEP employs customized learning instructions that can help the child learn despite the limitations that they have.

According to Klitze (2008), the impact of cross-cultural factors on a person’s life is only comprehended when examining the growth of individuals to understand how their needs and behavior changes at every developmental phase. Historical, cultural experts such as Hofstede believed that culture is created from collective thinking that one group of people has that is different from another group. Using this definition, the use of separate classes creates a perception, especially among kids at the early stages of development, such that children living with a disability are seen as different or given designated privileges. This has helped the marginalized group but still has remnants of negativity that develops from the effects on the learner’s adult life. The behaviors and values learned at such a young age are hard to change once every child adopts them into their culture. This culture refers to the basic concepts that the children will have regarding what pertains to the best-talented people or what is preferable under special circumstances. The idea that people living with a disability cannot perform the same activities as “healthy” children is incorrect. The effect of only using IEPs as the model of education for children with special needs creates kids with partial skills. This happens through the manifestation of power differences between individuals as young children accustomed to the different social status related to a person due to the physical features. Culture also pertains to the levels of individualism or collectivism that is cultivated among children at a young age. The IEPs have shown to produce a profound effect on how children living with disabilities are restrained from full participation in standard education programs.

The segregation of children with special needs was introduced as a measure of protecting children from other children, not as a tool for promoting equal benefits from the education curriculum. The belief of the government through its mandatory slots for children with special needs shows an outdated approach that does not mirror the strides made in female empowerment and the minority ethnic groups. Contemporary studies on this topic of accommodating children with special needs focus on the processes that render the individualized programs as void since they fail to improve the overall inclusion of students. According to Senecal (2001), the premises used to identify children with special disabilities require the students to fail to show that they are eligible for the special classes. The work involved between educators in the different programs that children with disabilities can reduce the effectiveness of the individualized programs. The author brings attention to an important topic, not all students with learning disabilities can effectively learn in an inclusive environment given the variety of learning disabilities that different children possess (Chesmore & Reynolds, 2016). The focus on the mental health of students has changed the shape of contemporary studies. The stigma that students get with the tag of special education or ‘a less-than-average’ capacity is a worrying mental health issue that negates the progress made on the cognitive development-acquisition of knowledge and skills.

Full inclusion is viewed with more appreciation since it provides the services required to help children with disabilities within the classroom and normal social activities. For instance, Smith (2007) shows evidence-based research that children with Down syndrome score higher on literacy tests and grammar comprehension when paired with other students in a natural learning environment. The type of curriculum provided under individualized education programs is tutored by paraprofessionals who are not masters of the educational program that other teachers offer to normal students. This is shown by the less number of hours that children under special education spend on traditional subjects such as mathematics, literature, and sciences.

Methodology

Evaluation Design and Data Collection Procedures

As mentioned earlier, the research evaluation will use the design of the process evaluation methodology. This type of assessment focuses on the activities within a program that are thought to lack the quality in offering a given service to a specific audience. This means that the data collection methodologies will significantly involve qualitative data collection. However, quantitative data collection techniques will be used in determining the numerical numbers of children living with special needs against the whole number of children that use the services of YvY Head Start programs. Qualitative research methodologies use structural thoughts and assessable experiences to infer meaning about variables under study (Royse, Thyer, & Padgett, 2009). This means that an inductive approach rather than a deductive approach is applied in the analysis tools. Unlike quantitative studies where a phenomenon is chosen to be studied, qualitative studies begin with broad research that is strategically pre-empted into the most relevant theories depending on the information collected. For instance, to understand the scope of the mental health effect has on children living with disabilities, the respondents will use narrations to define their feelings.

Sampling Design

The evaluation process will involve an expert review of the current practices at the program regarding the quality of services offered in special needs programs. The information collected will include data regarding the roles of students in the class, the responsibilities of the teachers, resources available and class materials used, and understanding of the population’s view on the procedures and practices of the organizations towards the special needs program. Aside from the observational aspect of the evaluation, representatives of the key stakeholders will be chosen randomly to participate in the evaluation process. Other general data for comparison will be sourced from the YvY records such as the total number of students in the program, the total number of facilities owned under the agency, the budgetary allocation to the special needs programs. This data will be compared against the needs of children living with disabilities, as collected from the sample population. The random sampling method will be applied to a section of the study. In contrast, stratified sampling will be utilized in identifying children with disabilities, who are then randomly selected to participate in the evaluation.

Description of Participants

The representatives of the population will involve people with different responsibilities in the program. One, the teachers from standard education programs and the special needs programs, will help in providing information regarding the current practices at the YvY Head Start programs. Second, parents living with children with disabilities will provide essential information regarding the progress of the child as they are the primary caregivers in the whole interconnected community. Finally, the actual participants in the program will be observed and surveyed using different instruments of data collection to determine their review of the programs.

The evaluation involves the participation of human subjects, which means that the HIPAA rules and regulations regarding privacy and consent will apply. Quantitative and qualitative designs involving human subjects entail ethical considerations, which are broadly assumed in all healthcare research studies (Royse, Thyer, & Padgett, 2009). The evaluators should seek the consent of the participants after ensuring that the latter understand all their rights and freedom to withdraw whenever they wish during the study. The evaluation must never bring harm, such as interfering with the learning process or expose the private information of a participant.

Description of Instrumentation

The qualitative data will be collected from the use of individual interviews with the different participants selected for the evaluation. To ensure that there is uniformity in the data collected, a questionnaire will be used by the evaluators that structure the questions in a logical manner that is applied for every subject. This is known as the structured interview instrument of data collection. Since the differences in performance of the programs involve several factors that will improve the service provision, a behavior and resource checklist will be used in the evaluation. The checklists will form part of the direct observations that the evaluators will perform in their review of the processes and practices applied within the special needs groups. Questionnaires will be the last instrument. The questionnaires will contain a different set of questions customized for the evaluation. This will help in collecting data from different groups of subjects, the opinion of parents, teachers, and young learners.

Procedures for Analyzing Data

In the data analysis of the quantitative data, the evaluation will employ the use of descriptive statistics, which will provide the necessary information regarding the summary and trends within the data. For instance, by calculating the percentages of a group expressed in terms of the total number of students helps in finding the persistent problems in enrollment and withdrawal numbers. The quantitative techniques can also involve the determination of the frequencies that a problem is noted within the data collected.

For the qualitative data, the techniques of analysis used will engage the correlation and regression between the variables. For instance, the correlation analysis is used to determine the type of relationship that exists between variables under study (Royse, Thyer, & Padgett, 2009). For instance, the education performance of children living with disabilities in standard tests against learning in an IEP program. The regression analysis is used to predict the trend in the relationship between two variables. For instance, this is used in the determination of the special programs on the mental health of students that undergo the YvY Head Start programs.

Results

In the city of New York in which the centers of YvY are scattered, the number of children under the age of six years who are eligible for the care services offered by the agency is over 100,000 according to the latest national statistics. Among this number, the total number of children with special needs is nearly 45%; that is 46,000 children that are on the waiting list of various agencies due to the lack of resources in multiple schools.

The number of children under the YvY agency serves over 12,300 children between the ages of 3 to 5 years. The main programs offered include early childhood education in subjects such as literature and numeracy. The latest introductions to the special needs program include attention to the healthcare and special needs of children living with a disability. For instance, the Special Education and Related Services program serves almost 1,000 children. The average teacher to child ratio under the program is one teacher for every 20 children.

As mentioned under the methodology, the evaluation will involve the determination of the health effects on the children by looking at the health records and calculating key descriptive statistics. For instance, the assessment will show that the YvY agency has shown a small increase in the mental healthcare needs of the children. For example, 15% of the children under the special education programs reduced their attendance to therapy sessions, while 25% of the population altogether stopped attending the therapy sessions after one year.

Some of the significant observations made during the evaluation are the use of supervision and training services to help in the continuous professional development of the special education itinerant teachers (SEIT). The organization centers have fully-equipped gyms, access areas, and specialty equipment for children living with physical disabilities. The headquarter center at Brooklyn was recently equipped with a therapy pool that provides an aquatic setting for concurrent therapy sessions.

Today, the organization is looking to expand the special needs program from the mandatory 10% to over 40% of the population. This is the group in need of the critical services that the agency hopes to provide. The following table shows the expected results in terms of performance of the children in different areas of development in Fig 1:

The evaluation pertaining to the family dynamics is explained in the following expected results in Fig 2:

Discussion

Explanation of Findings

The mental health of children that live with disabilities is a critical factor that child welfare agencies should prioritize, rather than merely passing standardized tests. While the intervention programs for students with special needs have had a positive influence on academic performance, there is sufficient data to show that the correlation with mental health is indirect. The performance of students in the socioemotional area of development was quite poor among young children who have developed cognitive awareness of the environment. This means that they have learned emotions of shame and realize the implication of good and bad behavior. At this age, special education is a distinguishing feature between healthy kids and children with disabilities.

The sampling of the different tests offered under the two distinct curriculums showed that the IEPs were often tedious and that the summarizations are significantly meant for regular education purposes. The studies provided under the program contain additional material or lesser material that does not fit into the typical curriculum. For instance, some of the lengthy tests offered under the program are quite repetitive, and the teachers do not understand the implications of a customized program and an accommodative class. Additionally, it is notable that the existence of resources to help children with disabilities to adopt the ‘best practices’ as outlined by the federal government. The interview of the parents showed that despite the prevalence of the home-based programs, there was little assistance offered to parents in understanding the practices that should be adopted at home. Finally, there was no semblance of any programs related to socio-emotional learning programs, which equips children with the necessary skills required in managing one’s feelings and reactions in unique situations. The inconsistencies in practice between the standard group and the special needs programs also show that the criteria of teaching are not uniformed and discriminates against one group. The parents of these children have to deal with the high cost of living and supplementary budget for the additional services that the children are offered separately.

Recommendations

The YvY should look to create a program and staff oversight committee that will continuously evaluate the capacity of current practices to meet the changing needs of the marginalized group within child welfare cases. The special needs program is intended to provide wholesome education without having to separate students from their peers without any expert motivation. The current level of staffing at YvY is working under extreme conditions, whereby the ratio of teachers to children is too big. For instance, the current evaluation programs only focus on the performance of students depending on the programs attended. However, this is a flawed strategy that assumes the students will work in different social environments when they graduate out of the programs.

Finally, the evaluation revealed that all the students under the YvY program are exhibiting higher mental and behavioral needs, which is the primary concern for this evaluation. Mental health symptoms that were significantly evaluated among students included the incidence of anxiety, social avoidance, and hesitance to join the special needs programs. It is, therefore, recommended that more therapists and counselors are added to meet the increasing demand for mental health services among children. The use of one-time training programs for teachers has also shown no lasting influence on the understanding of children’s mental health. As such, increased interaction with fellow peers and in a typical learning environment will improve the relationship between teachers and the students.

Limitations of the Study

The critical challenge in this evaluation will be to convince the staff members that the process is biased and will be used to determine the levels of performance of employees. The assessment is not an appraisal of employees. Still, it is aimed at examining the limitations within the processes of the YvY agency in terms of providing access to children with special needs. This concern among employees arises from misconceptions about program evaluation as cumbersome and detrimental to the sustainability of effective programs. Similarly, the staff should be made aware that the assessment is a formal continuation of other informal evaluation approaches such as supervision and auditing.

Another key problem identified in the evaluation process is in regards to the limited financial resources accessed through grants. Some stakeholders might argue that the evaluation is a waste of financial and human resources from the specific areas that the same assessment will find critical problems. The arbitrary standards of the discussion topic also raise concerns among the staff working at the agency. The organization has made remarkable strides and stands out amongst other educational facilities in the provision of services to children living with disabilities. As such, the proposal that these services are below par could induce a lack of motivation among the hardworking staff members that are contributing to the current levels of practice.

 

 

References

Chesmore, A., Ou, S. & Reynolds, A. (2016). Childhood Placement in Special Education and Adult Wellbeing. Journal of Special Education, Vol. 50 (2) 109-120.

Citigroup (2020). Boy and Girl YvY Plan. Retrieved on April 11, 2020, from https://www.yeled.org/ArticleFiles/YVYplan.pdf

Hofstede, G. (1980). “Culture’s Consequences: International Differences in Work-Related Values.” London: Sage Publications.

Klitze, M. (2008) “Working with families of children with developmental disabilities.” (Report No. 1556-7575). Child and Adolescent Behaviour Letter.

Prunty, A. (2011) “Implementation of children’s rights: What is in ‘the best interests of the child’ in relation to the individual reduction plan (IEP) process for pupils with autistic spectrum disorders (ASD)”? Irish Educational Studies, 30(1): 23-44.

Royse, D., Thyer, B. A., & Padgett, D. K. (2009). Program evaluation: An introduction. Cengage Learning.

Senecal, B. (2001). Academic and Social Outcomes of General Education Students in Inclusion versus Non-Inclusion Classrooms: A Case Study. University of Massachusetts Amherst.

Smith, D. (2007) “Introduction to Special Education,” Pearson Education, Inc.

Yeled Official Page (2020). https://www.yeled.org/

Yeledv’Yalda (2020). Yeledv’Yalda School Readiness Plan. Retrieved on April 11, 2020, from https://www.yeled.org/ArticleFiles/School%20Readiness%20Plans%20and%20Updates/School%20Readiness%20Addendum/Yeled%20v%27Yalda%20School%20Readiness%20Addendum.pdf

 

 

 

Appendix

Consent Form:

Participants will not be identified in any report or publication about this study. We may use de-identified data and/or specimens from this study in future evaluations without additional consent.

Although every effort will be made to keep research records private, there may be times when federal or state law requires the disclosure of such documents, including personal information. This is very unlikely, but if the disclosure is ever needed, YvY will take steps allowable by law to protect the privacy of personal information. In some cases, your information in this research study could be reviewed by representatives of the organization, research sponsors, or government agencies (for example, the FDA) for purposes such as quality control or safety.

Fig 1

The % of Children that Exceed Average Expectations: All Children
Gran Period 2020 Evaluation 2020 (Special Programs)
            N= 771
Ages N= 730 0-2

n=172

2-3

n=131

3-4

n= 221

4-5

n= 206

3-4

n= 472

4-5

n= 299

74%Areas of Development Socio-Emotional 81.5% 78.6% 67.0% 60.2% 80.7% 66.2%
Physical 91.2% 78.6% 77.8% 73.3% 84% 72%
Calculator

Calculate the price of your paper

Total price:$26

Need a better grade?
We've got you covered.

Order your paper