Performance Management Assignment | Online Homework Help

Description

Project Contents Cover Sheet Acknowledgement Table of Contents Executive Summary (1500 words) Scenario You are working for a Large High-tech manufacturing multinational company based in USA. You have factories in emerging countries (ECs)-China, India and South Korea. Your products are sold every over the world. Over the years you have also taken over many of electronics companies. You are a new HR manager, and you have been tasked with reviewing the performance management processes with a view to ensuring standardization of quality across the globe. You have also been asked to look at how the company measures and monitors the performance of its Knowledge Workers, such as designers and managers and general workers (different categories of employees), and report back to the management at headquarters. Introduction + Research Question/ Rationale + Aims and Objectives: (1000) words The purpose of this section is to develop a clear aim to inform the answering of the broad(er) topic question. In so doing a range of objectives will be established.  There should be background and contextual discussion/information to establish the relevance and validity of the aim (e.g. how big a market is; characteristics of a particular country etc.). In some cases students may use a/or series of ‘hypotheses’ instead of ‘aims’.  This section should present the reader with a clear picture of what the project is trying to achieve and how this is going to happen. There should be a recognition that this is not a ‘discrete’ section but that it also ‘introduces’ the subsequent sections of the project. Literature Review (3000) words Literature review structure: 1. Introduction to chapter (one paragraph) 2. Definition and explanation of key terms—define and critically analyse using key definitions from academics and practitioners 3. Historical evolution of the key terms—brief history of how this concept evolved in management 4. Key theories/models related to key terms—pick up few articles in your area and find out which theory/model is repeating 5. Empirical evidence—studies conducted in different context in your area 6. Summary of literature review (briefly- one paragraph) Case studies Analysis (3500) words 1. Walker, R.M & Jiannan, W. 2010 Future Prospects for Performance Management in Chinese City Governments. Administration and Society Vol 42:34S 2. Ohemeng, FLK. 2009 Constraints in the Implementation of Performance Management Systems in Developing Countries: The Ghanaian Case. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management Vol 9: 109 3. Nankervis, A.R, Compton R.L 2006 Performance Management: Theory in Practice. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources Vol 44 4. De Waal, A. Hafisi, R. Rahbar, AH, Rowshan, S. 2010 Studying Performance Management in Iran using an Adapted Performance Management Analysis. Journal of Transnational Management Vol 15: 246-264 5. Khanna, T. and Rivkin, J. W. (2001) Estimating the performance effects of business groups in emerging markets. Strategic Management Journal Volume 22, Issue 1, pages 45–74 This section concerns the application of knowledge to chosen case study organisations or examples. In all cases these case studies/examples MUST be based on secondary information sources.  The examples/cases should be carefully chosen to reflect both the overall topic area and the aim (i.e. the student’s choice should be justified).  Case studies should be described clearly (some of which may have occurred in the introductory background section).  There should be clear links made between the examples /cases and the literature investigated. For example, where examples/cases are doing what the literature suggests, or where they are not, or partially. The similarity/differences should form the basis of a clear discussion.  The discussion could occur in this section or in the next section. However, under normal circumstances case study analysis should not be incorporated into the literature review proper. Discussion (2000 words) This section should be pulling all the work thus far together and arrive at a response to the research question or topic as stated. Note, some of the discussion could well have occurred in the previous task when looking at the case/examples. It may be dealt with as a completely separate section. The project should have identified three key things by now:  1) background/contextual information,  2) knowledge derived from the literature review, and  3) the results of the case/examples. The ‘discussion’ should concern bringing all of this together and synthesising what has been found. Can reasons for differences between theory and practice be identified for example? To what extent is the context important (and perhaps not recognised, or identified, sufficiently within the literature)? Conclusions (500 words) The conclusion should likewise be looking specifically as to what extent the original aim has been satisfied – did the project achieve what itset out to achieve?  References to the original objectives would support the argument. All of this should be based on the work evidenced in the project and should not rely on new ideas/information suddenly introduced at this stage. Recommendations (500 words)  Any recommendations should be clearly based on the discussion/conclusion. They should be practical/applied in nature. References Appendixes

Don't use plagiarized sources. Get Your Custom Essay on
Performance Management Assignment | Online Homework Help
For $10/Page 0nly
Order Essay
Cover Sheet  
Acknowledgement  
Table of Contents  
Executive Summary (1500 words)  
Scenario

You are working for a Large High-tech manufacturing multinational company based in USA.  You have factories in emerging countries (ECs)-China, India and South Korea.  Your products are sold every over the world.  Over the years you have also taken over many of electronics companies.

You are a new HR manager, and you have been tasked with reviewing the performance management processes with a view to ensuring standardization of quality across the globe.  You have also been asked to look at how the company measures and monitors the performance of its Knowledge Workers, such as designers and managers and general workers (different categories of employees), and report back to the management at headquarters.

Introduction + Research Question/ Rationale + Aims and Objectives: (1000) words

The purpose of this section is to develop a clear aim to inform the answering of the broad(er) topic
question. In so doing a range of objectives will be established.

Ÿ There should be background and contextual discussion/information to establish the relevance and validity of the aim (e.g. how big a market is; characteristics of a particular country etc.). In some cases students may use a/or series of ‘hypotheses’ instead of ‘aims’.

Ÿ This section should present the reader with a clear picture of what the project is trying to achieve and how this is going to happen. There should be a recognition that this is not a ‘discrete’ section but that it also ‘introduces’ the subsequent sections of the project.

 
Literature Review (3000) words

Literature review structure:

1.       Introduction to chapter (one paragraph)

2.       Definition and explanation of key terms—define and critically analyse using key definitions from academics and practitioners

3.       Historical evolution of the key terms—brief history of how this concept evolved in management

4.       Key theories/models related to key terms—pick up few articles in your area and find out which theory/model is repeating

5.       Empirical evidence—studies conducted in different context in your area

6.       Summary of literature review (briefly- one paragraph)

 
Case studies Analysis (3500) words

1.       Walker, R.M & Jiannan, W. 2010 Future Prospects for Performance Management in Chinese City Governments. Administration and Society Vol 42:34S

2.       Ohemeng, FLK. 2009 Constraints in the Implementation of Performance Management Systems in Developing Countries: The Ghanaian Case. International Journal of Cross Cultural Management Vol 9: 109

3.       Nankervis, A.R, Compton R.L 2006 Performance Management: Theory in Practice. Asia Pacific Journal of Human Resources Vol 44

4.       De Waal, A. Hafisi, R. Rahbar, AH, Rowshan, S. 2010  Studying Performance Management in Iran using an Adapted Performance Management Analysis. Journal of Transnational Management Vol 15: 246-264

5.       Khanna, T. and Rivkin, J. W. (2001) Estimating the performance effects of business groups in emerging markets. Strategic Management Journal Volume 22, Issue 1, pages 45–74

This section concerns the application of knowledge to chosen case study organisations or examples. In all cases these case studies/examples MUST be based on secondary information sources.

Ÿ The examples/cases should be carefully chosen to reflect both the overall topic area and the aim (i.e. the student’s choice should be justified).

Ÿ Case studies should be described clearly (some of which may
have occurred in the introductory background section).

Ÿ There should be clear links made between the examples /cases and the literature investigated. For example, where examples/cases are doing what the literature suggests, or where they are not, or partially. The similarity/differences should form the basis of a clear discussion.

Ÿ The discussion could occur in this section or in the next section. However, under normal circumstances case study analysis should not be incorporated into the literature review proper.

 
Discussion (2000 words)

This section should be pulling all the work thus far together and arrive at a response to the research question or topic as stated. Note, some of the discussion could well have occurred in the previous task when looking at the case/examples. It may be dealt with as a completely separate section. The project should have identified three key things by now:
Ÿ 1) background/contextual information,
Ÿ 2) knowledge derived from the literature review, and
Ÿ 3) the results of the case/examples.

The ‘discussion’ should concern bringing all of this together and synthesising what has been found. Can reasons for differences between theory and practice be identified for example? To what extent is the context important (and perhaps not recognised, or identified, sufficiently within the literature)?

 
Conclusions (500 words)

The conclusion should likewise be looking specifically as to what extent the original aim has been satisfied – did the project achieve what itset out to achieve?
n References to the original objectives would support the argument. All of this should be based on the work evidenced in the project and should not rely on new ideas/information suddenly introduced at this stage.

 
Recommendations (500 words)

n Any recommendations should be clearly based on the discussion/conclusion. They should be
practical/applied in nature.

 
References  
AppendixesFuture Prospects for Performance Management in Chinese City Governments
Richard M. Walker1,2 and Jiannan Wu3
Abstract
Contrasting views are presented on the nature and rationale for public management reforms in China. One school argues that they are strongly influenced by international practice, whereas the other holds that they reflect the characteristics of Chinese politics and administration. The authors explore this proposition in the arena of performance management, where they pay particular attention to whether future prospects for performance management are likely to be associated with international practice or Chinese characteristics. The authors’ concern with the future leads them to implement a Delphi study focusing on performance management in city governments, from which they find that performance management has particular Chinese characteristics and that it will continue to be used as a control mechanism. However, expert respondents also indicate the desirability of orienting performance management and evaluation outward to citizens and other key stakeholders, and of enhancing service delivery and performance, in keeping with the international performance management movement. The authors conclude by discussing the research and practice implications of these findings.
Keywords
performance management, performance evaluation, Chinese city governments, Delphi method
1 University of Hong Kong, China
2 Cardiff University, Wales, United Kingdom
3 Xi’an Jiaotong University, China
Corresponding Author:
Richard M. Walker, Department of Sociology and Kadoorie Institute, 8/F, TT Tsui Building, University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam Rd., Hong Kong, China
Email: rwalker@hku.hk
361853AAS10.1177/0095399710361853Walker and WuAdministration & Society
Walker and Wu 35S
In the past 30 years, questions about the performance of public organizations have become prevalent internationally. Performance evaluation, performance management, or managing for results have become key tools for raising the performance of public agencies, and they remain a central concern in the field of public management research and practice (Behn, 2003; Moynihan, 2006; OECD, 2005; Pollitt & Bouckeart, 2006). Within nations across the globe, the adoption of the New Public Management reforms and management practices from the private sector has accelerated the trend. This change has moved beyond the Anglo-Saxon countries where it was first popularized, and a now-notable example is China, where various forms of performance evaluation have been implemented (Chan & Gao, 2008, 2009; Walker & Moon, 2007; Westcott & Jones, 2007). Although the measurement of performance is complex, and the adoption of performance measurement and evaluation techniques demanding, it has been increasingly accepted as a management tool that permits more informed decisions and has the intention of achieving improvement in public service. It remains an important area therefore for systematic research.
There has been an explosion of performance evaluation in Chinese cities in recent years (Chan & Gao, 2008). The research thus far examines performance management and evaluation in one locality (Dai & Teng, 2008; Gao, 2007) or for single agencies (Lui, 1995) or focuses on one segment of the performance management system (Chen, Li, & Zhou, 2005). The detailed research questions in this study examine (a) why and how performance management regimes are used, (b) which stakeholders are involved in the process, and (c) what dimensions of performance are prioritized. In answering these questions, we seek to contribute toward a debate at the heart of public management reform by examining whether current practices and future priorities are driven by the international trend toward performance management or by internal concerns within individual countries. This is an important question for reform in China, given China’s political and administrative system, and a debate has emerged around this issue (Chan & Chow, 2007; Chan & Gao, 2009; Foster, 2006; Ngok & Zhu, 2007). Because we are oriented toward the future and the ways in which performance management priorities may change in the short term, we have adopted the Delphi method. This widely utilized forecasting technique is employed when information about the future is uncertain and requires subjective data. The method tackles problems of uncertainty by drawing on the knowledge of experts and seeking consensus on the topic under investigation.
We have structured the balance of the study as follows. We review the literature on performance management and evaluation, with a focus on the
36S Administration & Society 42(1S)
Chinese context of our study, and tease out evidence on the influences that contributed to the adoption of management reforms. We then discuss the Delphi method and our samples and measures before we present the findings of our study. These findings indicate the importance of both the local context and international processes; we identified both an ongoing emphasis on managing upward to higher levels of political authority and downward within the organization, but we also note a desire to manage outward toward citizens, which reflects the emphasis on accountability found in performance management elsewhere in the world. Finally, we discuss the implications of these findings, which strengthen the argument for the use of contingency frameworks, in the conclusion.
Management Reform and Managing
Performance in China
Research reporting the development of performance management in China presents two somewhat contrasting views. The Chinese perspective is
of specific strategies and tools being developed in response to local
circumstances (Chan & Chow, 2007; Chan & Gao, 2009; Gao, 2009;
Gong, 2009). However, a number of observers see management reform, and performance management in particular, as a response to economic liberalization and the resulting decentralization of systems, which requires the adoption of a range of management practice that are influenced by international practice (Caulfield, 2006; Chou, 2008; Christensen, Dong, & Painter, 2008; Foster, 2006; Painter, 2008). Indeed, Ngok and Zhu (2007) go so far as to argue that “the entire process of administrative reform, ‘with Chinese characteristics,’ as many scholars often qualify it, has coincided with the world administrative reform trend” (p. 218).
The international literature contends that performance management has been adopted as a mechanism to attain accountability, whether this is politicians seeking to hold bureaucrats accountable or for purposes of internal management, and to enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of government and increase its responsiveness (OECD, 2005). This line of reasoning draws on public choice theory, which argues that information is vested in bureaucrats and the provision of performance data to politicians and citizens can reduce the information asymmetry (Boyne, Farrell, Law, Powell, & Walker, 2003). To use Moore’s (1995) terminology of managing upward, downward, and outward, performance management is used across all these directions—upward from the bureaucracy to provide information to politicians, who in turn use it downward to hold officials to account; it is also used outward to
Walker and Wu 37S
permit citizens to question politicians and their servants. Offering empirical support of the internationalization hypothesis, Foster (2006) presents a detailed case study of the implementation of, and subsequent nationwide adoption of, the Service Promise System in the city of Yantai. Although Foster (2006) notes the “CCP’s [Chinese Communist Party’s] continuing aversion to being bound by clear and enforceable rules and by public opinion” (p. 241), he ultimately concludes that the Service Promise System is an international tool from the New Public Management rubric and represents “a serious attempt to make the bureaucracy more customer-orientated and professional” (p. 221). Foster’s study, then, sits within broader arguments and justifications for the adoption of performance management (also see Caulfield, 2006; Christensen et al., 2008).
Three arguments associated with Chinese characteristics have been presented for the adoption of performance management: to manage central–local relations, to enhance state capacity, and to manage and control local officials (Gao, 2009). Performance management is the modern tool the Chinese central government has adopted to exert influence over the many administrative levels of government and, in particular, over the great distance between the central and local governments in the policy-implementation chain. The structure of Chinese government means that performance management is concerned not only with service performance but also with maintaining a stable, harmonious society and promoting economic and sustainable development. The hierarchical nature of government means that performance management is “used chiefly to ensure that local officials comply with higher-level policy priorities” and that “by binding local officials’ target accomplishments to their career future the target-based responsibility system guarantees that local officials will follow the directives that come down from above” (Chan & Gao, 2008, p. 8).
The primary aim within China is to manage upward to the higher levels of government and downward to ensure that the local level implements nationally identified performance targets. This suggests that there is little drive attached to managing outward for “accountability,” with the ultimate aim of “enhanced outcomes for society” (OECD, 2005, p. 56). This assertion can be illustrated with evidence from Gao’s (2009) case study in Zhouzhi County in Xi’an City. Gao’s study concludes that performance management has been introduced to assist with state capacity building within government and to enhance policy implementation. The performance targets used are able to achieve the desired outcomes because they specify the policy objectives of a higher level of government, which holds lower level cadres accountable for ensuring that CCP policies are implemented (Caulfield, 2006; Gao, 2007).
38S Administration & Society 42(1S)
These outcomes are achieved through the Objective Responsibility System (ORS), which was initially promulgated in the mid-1980s to meet the needs of Chinese government (Chan & Gao, 2008).
The conflation of politics and bureaucracy in the Chinese system of government has important implications for the role of stakeholders and their consequent ability to influence performance management. We draw on the work of Mitchell, Agle, and Wood (1997, p. 869), who argue that stakeholders express three characteristics. Power implies the ability of one actor to influence another actor and to get that individual to do something that the individual would otherwise not have done, by means that may be coercive or normative or via incentives. Legitimacy derives from norms, values, and beliefs in a social system and promotes the authority of some stakeholders over others. Finally, different stakeholders are able to confer urgency on a public agency; urgency is likely to be measured by the time and extent to which it is acceptable to delay responding to the stakeholder.
The “Chinese characteristics” hypothesis suggests that internal stakeholders are those most likely to be powerful, legitimate, and have urgency. If this is the case, the main pattern of management would be accountability upward to higher levels of government and management downward to direct improved performance because civil servants and politicians are conflated into one body, as the CCP shadows bureaucratic positions. In this unitary and highly concentrated system, conflicts of interest can, nonetheless, arise. For example, audit bodies are not structurally independent; they can be commissioned by and report to the same agency or be required to audit departments that are responsible for personnel matters within the audit agency (Li, 2009). Alternatively, decentralization has increased the freedom of local cadres, which has resulted in them promoting their own interests above those of the party and national policies (Gao, 2009). The role of external stakeholders in public management processes has been shown to be limited, but useful to assist with capacity building (Li, 2009). On the other hand, there is some evidence that a wider set of factors may drive current practice and future priorities—regimes also now focus on citizens and have developed characteristics of outward management, in keeping with international practices (Christensen et al., 2008).
Method
“The Delphi Method is an exercise in group communication among a
panel of geographically dispersed experts . . . [it] allows experts to deal systematically with a complex problem or task” (Ziglio, 1996, p. 9). The key
Walker and Wu 39S
characteristics of the Delphi method include repetitive processes, panelist anonymity, controlled feedback, and a group statistical response (Alder & Ziglio, 1996; Linstone & Turoff, 2002). The Delphi method structures and refines large amounts of information to achieve and improve judgments and decision making. The notion of informed judgment is central to policy making and to the Delphi methodology, which seeks to acquire systematic context-dependent information from experts by using rounds of questionnaires (Engles & Powell Kennedy, 2007). Considerable expertise now exists on the Delphi method, and it is being widely used in the social sciences (Landeta, 2006) and among public administration scholars (see Critcher & Gladstone, 1998; Proeller, 2006; Torres, 2005).
We adopted the Delphi method to examine our research questions because it allows us both to draw a baseline of current practice from expert actors and to consider the direction of change in the future—the alternative is to look backward, which is replete with bias and recall errors. We focus on future scenarios to ascertain the extent to which respondents prioritize the more international aspects of performance management as against Chinese practices, without differentiating between these aims, and to draw on their informed judgment about their locality to achieve a wider view for China more generally. Surveying experts in this way also involves balancing researcher and subject bias, that is, ensuring that respondents are impartial while having an interest in the research topic. Subject bias may be exacerbated where individuals responding to the survey are likely to be affected by decisions made within the policy area under investigation. However, one important aspect of the Delphi approach is that it seeks to bring about consensus between participants by sharing information. Recognizing this key difference between Delphi and other research methods assists in addressing some of these concerns.
In this study we sampled all members of the Performance Government Management Research Association, a group established by Chinese Public Administration Society under the auspices of the Office of the State Council and Ministry of Civil Affairs. Its aims are to promote research on and the practice of performance management in the public sector. Membership is based on expertise in performance management through academic reputation or civil service position. There are a total of 151 members—80 practitioners, 66 academics, and 5 from enterprises.
We invited all association members to join the Delphi process and received positive responses from 34 members, split equally between academics and practitioners. Reasons for declining the invitation ranged from being too busy to concerns about the sensitivity of the topic. Attrition in Round 2
40S Administration & Society 42(1S)
reduced our respondent pool to 26 experts, and analysis is based on these matched respondents. Panel members were drawn from different economic regions of China: 14 from the east (including Beijing and Shanghai), and 6 each from mid-China (e.g., Hubei and Jiangxi provinces), and 7 from west China (including Chongqing and Shaanxi provinces). Of the academic participants, 11 were full professors and 3 were associates, while the practitioners split half and half between departmental and divisional levels. All panelists had published on the topic, with a mean of 5.4 articles for the academics and 3 for the practitioners. The assessments by academics and practitioners were similar, with only a handful of statistically significant differences.
Delphi statements were written in English and translated to Chinese prior to the survey being administered. To ensure the translation was accurate, the Chinese-language version of the survey was translated back into English to ensure consistency in interpretation. This exercise led to a number of small changes made in the characters used in the final Chinese-language version of the survey.
We draw our measures from our reading in performance measurement literature and current practice within China. (The statements in the Delphi appear in Table 2 through 5.) The first part of the survey we report examined “Evaluation reasons: Why undertake performance evaluation in your city?” Detailed measures were taken from Behn’s (2003) study on the purposes of performance measurement and were supplemented with questions of innovation (service, process, and partnership) and cost reduction. We then moved on to examine “Results application: Use of the performance evaluation ranking and rating results in your city,” for which items were drawn from knowledge of current practice among Chinese city authorities. “Stakeholders: Different groups of key actors consulted during your city’s performance evaluation,” were examined in the third part of the study, where we quizzed respondents about a range of key stakeholders inside and outside the organization (Andrews, Boyne, & Walker, 2006). In the final part of the survey we examined the dimensions of performance used in each city government
   

 

 

 

 

Calculator

Calculate the price of your paper

Total price:$26

Need a better grade?
We've got you covered.

Order your paper