How would you rule if this case were brought in your court and you were the presiding judge? | Homework Help
FORUM #1 Tort Litigation and the Fast Food Industry
Read the following case. Consider the two questions at the end of the case. Based on the principles of law covered in the text, express your opinion in the Forum. Also, be prepared to comment on someone elses remarks on this case, preferably an individual who has a contrasting point of view from the one that you have.
Caesar Barber, from the Bronx, New York, weighs 272 pounds. He filed a lawsuit against McDonalds, Kentucky Fried Chicken, Wendys, and Burger King for contributing to his weight problem. He has a number of health problems commonly associated with high weight two heart attacks, diabetes, high blood pressure, and high cholesterol. He claims the fast food chains deceived him with ads that said 100 percent beef and they created a de facto aIDiction. The case alleges that McDonalds failed to adequately disclose material facts about its high fat food. The law of warnings is not designed for the best and brightest of us . It is aimed at helping people who need to be told not to stand on the top step of a laIDer or not to use a hair dryer in the bathtub, says John Banzhaf, a legal activism teacher at George Washington University Law School. All of the restaurants have nutritional information available on request in their restaurants and online. The plaintiff claims that he didnt know how fattening or harmful the food was. The TV and print ads promoted the foods as healthy, economical, tasty, and convenient. Also, it is alleged by plaintiffs that the fast food restaurants could use healthier ways to prepare the food. Hence this lawsuit was filed.
1.How would you rule if this case were brought in your court and you were the presiding judge?
2. Should the fast food restaurants be held liable? If so, what legal theories covered would be applicable?
CASE FOR FORUM #2
PGA Tour, Inc., sponsors professional golf tournaments. A player may enter in several ways, but the most common method is to successfully compete in a three-stage qualifying tournament known as the Q-School. Anyone may enter the Q-School by submitting two letters of recommendation and paying $3,000 to cover greens fees and the cost of a golf cart, which is permitted during the first two stages, but is prohibited during the third stage. The rules governing the events include the Rules of Golf, which apply at all levels of amateur and professional golf and do not prohibit the use of golf carts, and the hard card, which applies specifically to the PGA tour and requires the players to walk the course during most of a tournament. Casey Martin is a talented golfer with a degenerative circulatory disorder that prevents him from walking golf courses. Martin entered the Q-School and asked for permission to use a cart during the third stage. PGA refused. Martin filed a suit in a federal district court against PGA, alleging a violation of the Americans with Disabilities Act. Is a golf cart in these circumstances a reasonable accommodation under the ADA? Why or why not? [PGA Tour, Inc. v. Martin, 532 U.S. 661, 121 S.Ct. 1879, 149 L.Ed.2d 904 (2001)]
The court ordered PGA to permit Martin to use a cart. PGA appealed to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, which affirmed the order of the lower court. PGA appealed to the United States Supreme Court, which affirmed the lower courts decision, ruling that a golf cart is a reasonable accommodation for a disabled athlete. PGA argued that making an exception to its walking rule would fundamentally alter the sport of golf. The Supreme Court disagreed, stating that the [u]se of a cart is not inconsistent with the fundamental character of the game of golf, PGAs tours, or the third stage of the Q-School. Golf is defined by shot-making, not by walking. The Court explained that the ADA is applied case by case. In other words, [t]he needs of a disabled person [is] evaluated on an individual basis. Thus, in this case, [e]ven if petitioners factual predicate is accepted, its legal position is fatally flawed because its refusal to consider Martins personal circumstances in deciding whether to accommodate his disability runs counter to the ADAs requirement that an individualized inquiry be conducted.
First, read the Forum case provided in this session. Next, enter the Forum and give your opinion as to whether you agree or disagree with the Supreme Courts ruling in this case. If you were on the court, how would you have ruled? Has the game of golf been altered or equalized? Should ADA apply in this matter? Give your opinion and state reasons for your answer. Also, be sure to respond to someone in the Forum who disagrees with your position or comment on something that someone said that you found interesting.
CASE FOR FORUM #3
You are interested in setting up a business which would make and sell custom designed handbags in shops and on the internet. You have four seamstresses who are experts in quilting, cross-stitching, and doing needlepoint that you will be hiring. You are going to contact individual stores, boutiques, and accessory shops as well as individual consumers. You have about a quarter of a million dollars already invested into this business venture. A friend of yours is also interested in joining you and he can put up one hundred thousand dollars. You have decisions yet to make about design, advertising, meshing online business with brick and mortar. But the first decision is : What form of organization should this business be in? Should it be a proprietorship, a general or limited partnership, a public or closed corporation.
Before you answer the above question as to form of organization, reflect on the chapters 23 and 24 previously covered. Also go to :
http://smallbusiness.findlaw.com/incorporation-and-legal-structures/benefits-and-drawbacks-of-different-types-of-business-entities.html (Links to an external site.)Links to an external site.
At that site, review the advantages and disadvantages of the business organizations listed,
Having read the chapters and the info on the website , participate in the forum.
Tell us what form that you think is the best for this startup business. Give reasons for your opinion by referencing material from the articles or the chapter. Also, respond and react to at least one other person starting with someone who has taken a different opinion than the one that you hold. So read, reflect and react. I am looking forward to your input in the forum.
This is a forum about selecting an appropriate business organization.. Read and review the Instructions for this Forum in the Week #12 module. After doing that, participate in the forum by indicating your opinion. Also, be sure to respond and react to at least one other person, starting with someone with a different point of view than the one that you hold. In your responses, try to use the points of law covered in the text. So read, reflect, and react. I am looking forward to your input in the forum.